Skip to content 
Buying a home is one of the most significant financial decisions most people will ever make. With so much money and emotion on the line, it’s easy to get swept away by beautiful staging, a great location, or the thought of finally owning your dream property. But here’s the truth: not everything is as perfect as it appears during a showing.
Sellers (and their agents) know how to highlight a home’s best features while distracting you from potential problems. That’s why, as a buyer, it’s crucial to enter each showing with your eyes wide open. Recognizing red flags early can save you from costly repairs, endless headaches, or even a bad investment.
Below are the most common red flags to watch for during a home showing—and how to spot them before it’s too late.
1. Overpowering Scents or Strong Air Fresheners
When you walk into a showing and the home smells like a candle store, it might not just be for ambiance. While a pleasant scent can make a space feel inviting, overly strong air fresheners or scented candles may be masking odors—like mold, pet urine, or cigarette smoke.
What to do: Turn off your “it smells nice” brain and look deeper. Step into rooms without ventilation, sniff around closets, and check basements or attics where unpleasant odors are harder to hide.
2. Fresh Paint in Odd Places
A freshly painted wall can be a good thing—it updates the look and feel of a home. But if one wall, ceiling patch, or small area looks freshly painted while the rest is dated, it could be covering water damage, mold, or cracks.
What to do: Look closely at the texture of the painted area. Is it slightly different? Does it feel damp? You might need to ask the seller directly or get an inspector to check it out.
3. Water Stains and Signs of Moisture
Discoloration on ceilings, warped baseboards, or bubbling paint can all point to leaks or water damage. Even small water stains can indicate bigger problems, like a leaking roof, poor plumbing, or drainage issues.
Why it matters: Water damage doesn’t just ruin aesthetics—it can cause mold growth and structural damage.
What to do: Check under sinks, around toilets, in the basement, and along window sills for moisture. If you spot something suspicious, make a note for your home inspection.
4. Sloping or Uneven Floors
Uneven floors can be caused by natural settling in older homes, but in some cases, they’re a sign of serious foundation problems.
Signs to watch for:
- A ball rolling on its own when placed on the floor
- Gaps under baseboards
- Doors that don’t close properly
What to do: Don’t panic immediately—minor settling is common. But significant sloping or cracks in foundation walls should be evaluated by a structural engineer before making an offer.
5. Strange Smells in the Basement
Basements can tell you a lot about a home. A musty or earthy smell often points to moisture problems. A strong chemical smell could indicate recent pest treatment or even attempts to mask mold odors.
What to do: Look for a dehumidifier running in the corner, damp spots on the floor, or efflorescence (white powdery residue) on the walls—these are signs of water intrusion.
6. Poorly Done Repairs
While DIY fixes can save money, sloppy repairs can indicate the seller cut corners—possibly to quickly prepare the home for sale.
Examples include:
- Uneven tile work
- Mismatched flooring
- Cheap patch jobs over drywall holes
- Caulking that looks rushed
Why it matters: Poor repairs can fail quickly, leading to more costs for you.
7. Outdated or Damaged Roof
Replacing a roof is expensive, so it’s worth paying attention during a showing. Look for missing shingles, sagging areas, or visible patches.
What to do: From the ground, check for uneven lines and discoloration. Ask the seller when the roof was last replaced and if there are any warranties still in place.
8. Signs of Pest Infestations
Bugs and rodents aren’t just unpleasant—they can damage wiring, insulation, and wood framing.
Warning signs include:
- Droppings in corners or under cabinets
- Chewed wires or wood
- Nesting material in the attic or basement
- Small holes along baseboards
What to do: Don’t just look—listen. Sometimes you can hear movement in walls or ceilings in quiet moments during a showing.
9. Windows That Won’t Open or Close
If windows are stuck shut, painted over, or won’t latch, it could be more than just a minor inconvenience. This can point to foundation shifts, water damage, or even mold swelling the wood frames.
What to do: Test multiple windows in different parts of the home. Functioning windows are important for ventilation, safety, and energy efficiency.
10. Odd or Overly Concealing Staging
Home staging is meant to show the potential of a space, but sometimes it’s strategically used to hide problems.
Be suspicious if:
- Large rugs are covering strange spots on the floor
- Furniture blocks access to certain areas
- Drapes are drawn tight during the day (possibly hiding window damage)
What to do: Politely ask to move things or check behind them. You’re buying the house—not the perfect furniture arrangement.
11. Inconsistent Flooring
If flooring changes drastically from room to room, it might just be a style choice—or it could signal past water damage or incomplete renovations.
What to do: Pay attention to transitions between rooms. Are they uneven or creaky? That could mean repairs were rushed.
12. Cracks in Walls or Ceilings
Hairline cracks can be normal as a house settles, but large diagonal cracks, especially near windows or doors, may indicate foundation movement.
What to do: Note their size and location. Horizontal cracks in the basement are especially concerning and should be checked by an expert.
13. Electrical Red Flags
Old wiring, overloaded outlets, or visible electrical tape in the breaker box can mean costly upgrades are needed.
Check for:
- Flickering lights
- Warm outlets
- Two-prong outlets (no grounding)
14. Overly Rushed Showings
If the seller’s agent seems to be hurrying you through the home, discouraging questions, or avoiding certain rooms, it’s a red flag in itself. Transparency is key when buying a property.
Why These Red Flags Matter
Spotting these warning signs doesn’t necessarily mean you should walk away from a property—but they do mean you should proceed with caution. Many issues can be fixed or negotiated into the price, but only if you identify them before making an offer.
Final Tips for Buyers
- Always bring a checklist of potential red flags to every showing.
- Take photos or notes so you remember details later.
- Never skip the home inspection, even if the house looks perfect.
- If something feels “off,” trust your instincts and investigate further.
Buying a home isn’t just about falling in love with how it looks—it’s about making sure it’s safe, sound, and worth your investment. By staying alert and recognizing these common red flags, you can protect yourself from expensive surprises and make a confident, informed purchase.
